This week, we look into the sleepy town of Eufaula, Oklahoma, where a down on their luck, and meth addled couple hatch an ill conceived plan that leads to a brutal double murder. Anyone with any information that may contribute to the investigation is urged to call the Eufaula Police Department at 334-687-1200 or the Anonymous Tip Line at 334-687-7100. Pittsburg County Sheriff Chris Morris says it's taken a long time to get all the evidence in place to get a warrant for the arrest of Ketchum. She pleaded guilty in February 1998 to forgery and receiving stolen property and received a three-year deferred sentence. Along the way, we find out exactly how hard it is to escape to Mexico, how much worm dung one would need to farm to make a living, and how easy it seems to be . Your chance of becoming a victim of any of these crimes in Eufaula is one in 59. 10/14/2017 Related Story:Suspect Arrested In Eufaula Man's Death. EUFAULA The Bank of Eufaulas president was fatally shot and the gunman was killed after a subsequent police pursuit Thursday morning in McIntosh County, authorities said. When she resisted, the man shot her, Weber said. Harold McElmurry, 29, and Vickie McElmurry, 24, were driving a car that belonged to murder victims Robert and Vivian Pendley, investigators said. Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his body . Discover your neighborhood's best match, anywhere. Short's body was found five days later near Grove. Two other people were wounded in a series of events that began at the bank and ended in a shootout off a highway north of Eufaula. "It looks like we werent doing anything but it just takes time to do it right.. (renews at {{format_dollars}}{{start_price}}{{format_cents}}/month + tax). Who Is Kegan Kline, the Alleged Catfisher Being Investigated in Delphi Girls' Murder Case? The agency did not identify the victims or give their ages, but the Barbour County coroner has said a woman and two children were dead, according to NBC affiliate WSFA of Montgomery. A $30,000 reward is still being offered for information leading to the killer's arrest. Get the Android Weather app from Google Play, New Executive Chef joins Columbus Convention & Trade, SoftVuescreening is lifesaving for the 40% of, CDL operator shortage impacts METRA Transit of Columbus, University System of Georgia names finalist for CSU, Taylor County, Hardaway Girls advance to GHSA Final, CCSD announces two-hour delayed start on Thursday, Pacelli Beats Brookstone in Elite 8, Advances to, Spencer beats Butler, Advances to Elite Eight, Carver, Hardaway Girls advance to GHSA Elite Eight, CPD searching for missing teen last seen on Caspian, Super Bowl Champion shares passion for reading, Heated 2 hours of public agenda draws crowds at City. Significantly, based on the number of murders reported by the FBI and the number of residents living in the city, NeighborhoodScout's analysis shows that Eufaula experiences one of the higher murder rates in the nation when compared with cities and towns for all sizes of population, from the largest to the smallest. Nine days later, the family's abandoned . Ultimately, Morris says his department took the case to a grand jury to subpoena witnesses. We promise to never spam you. Crime in Eufaula, Oklahoma (OK): murders, rapes, robberies, assaults, burglaries, thefts, auto thefts, arson, law enforcement employees, police officers, crime map All Cities Oklahoma, Oklahoma smaller cities, Oklahoma small towns Eufaula main page US Crime Crime rate in Eufaula, Oklahoma (OK) Cantrell, a pregnant mother of three, disappeared on Jan. 20, 2017 while on her lunch break from the McAlester Regional Health Clinic. This is a senseless tragedy that hits way too close to home. his wife Sherilynn, and their six-year-old daughter Madyson were living what appeared to be normal lives in Eufaula, Okla. until Oct. 8, 2009. "Oh, God," she said upon seeing the cameras clicking and flashing at her. sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state. I live here in Eufaula for a reason, and thats scary that something like that would happen here in this small town we call home, Harris said. LeMasters, Jr., Associate District Judge. Robert Simpson, the banks owner, told The Oklahoman that the events at the bank were unconventional. You can opt-out at any time. Norris served prison time from 1994 to 2000 for Creek County weapons convictions. Prosecutors charged William Brown with first-degree murder. Property crimes are motor vehicle theft, arson, larceny, and burglary. The assailant then approached a teller, from whom he took an undisclosed amount of money. MCALESTER, Okla. 2 News is learning new details about the investigation of the murder of Holly Cantrell. This is important because the overall crime rate can be further illuminated by understanding if violent crime or property crimes (or both) are the major contributors to the general rate of crime in Eufaula. Violent Crime Comparison (per 1,000 residents), Property Crime Comparison (per 1,000 residents). You never stop thinking about them, Dave Freeman, who grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown, told PEOPLE. Another charge of concealing stolen property was dismissed in an apparent plea agreement. Investigators are unsure whether the man had gone into the bank with the intention of robbing it, Weber said. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Raw crime incidents are sourced from all 18,000+ local law enforcement agencies municipal, county, transit, park, port, university, tribal and more, assigned to localities, then built into NeighborhoodScouts proprietary predictive models to provide a comprehensive crime risk profile for every neighborhood and address-vicinity in the U.S. More about NeighborhoodScouts crime data methodology, By sending this Report you agree to NeighborhoodScout's, My Chances of Becoming a Victim of a This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. . When buying cowboy boots, there are a few aspects to consider, such as how far up they go on your legs and their design. When they went to his work to take him into custody, Morris says Ketchum dropped his head and never said a word, complying with law enforcement. Kirkpatrick said he wishes the McElmurrys would receive something "like in the old times - hanging, the electric chair or gas.". After receiving money, Fleming turned and fired one round from a gun, striking a man in the left leg. Morris says waiting for those two years for an ID was the most frustrating part of this investigation. There is no word on their condition at this time. The McIntosh County Sheriff's Department has released the names of the two male victims who were shot and their bodies burned in Eufaula . Then cast your vote, Bruce Springsteen adds to mythology with three-hour show at Tulsa's BOK Center, State board approves new academic standards with Ryan Walters' last-minute revisions, Gov. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police dog and its handler are among the law enforcement officials from multiple agencies at the site of a fatal shooting in McIntosh County on Thursday. Shannon Agofsky was convicted in Oklahoma of Shorts death, but jurors failed to convict Joseph Agofsky for the death and prosecutors declined to try him a second time. In 2013, hunters found the family's skeletal remains three miles away, lying face down and side-by-side in the woods. Please refer to our. A Eufaula man is charged with murder for the death Damion Martin. We could put this chapter behind us and move on to the next. McElmurry, 24, and her husband, Harold Loyd McElmurry, 29, made their first court appearance Wednesday in the beating and stabbing deaths of an elderly couple. Mom, Interview Transcripts from Delphi Murder Case Reveal Man Admitted to Communicating with Libby German, Delphi Murders: 5 Years Later, Victim's Sister Clinging to Hope That Killer Will Be Caught. The jury found David D. Martin, 31, of Eufaula guilty of first-degree murder. Violent Copyright 2022 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Store employees then called the police, she said. Listen to this episode from Small Town Murder on Spotify. In the In October 2009, Bobby, 44, 40-year-old Sherilyn Jamison and their 6-year-old daughter, Madyson, mysteriously vanished in the town of Eufaula, Oklahoma. Oct. 6, 1989: Joseph and Shannon Agofsky abducted bank president Dan Short from his home in rural Benton County, Arkansas, and drove him to the State Bank of Noel, Missouri, where he was forced to open the vault and the brothers stole about $71,000. Both were convicted again, with Neill sentenced to death and Johnson given four no-parole life sentences. EUFAULA, Ala. (WRBL) A Saturday afternoon shooting in the area of South Randolph Avenue in Eufaula claimed the life of one man and left another seriously injured. According to Eufaula Chief of Police, Steve Watkins, around 3:28pm the EPD Communications Division received multiple reports of gunshots. A line of storms swept across Oklahoma Sunday night, leaving many structures damaged and a new record for the highest total of monthly tornadoes. The McElmurrys later said they were trying to return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said. The couple had performed odd jobs for the Pendleys for a couple of days before the killings, said Joe Hogan, deputy regional inspector for the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. The man is identified as 34-year-old Trevor Armstrong. Crime. Killillay was the owner of the burned residence, detectives said. If you use a windshield cover, you can at least forget about scrapping the ice off your windshield to save some time and hassle. It would be wonderful if they called us and said, This is it, Becky Patty, Libertys grandmother, told PEOPLE in September. A second gunshot victim arrived at Medical Center Barbour via personal vehicle. It was her first time to ever go to camp anywhere., 'People Magazine Investigates' Examines How Authorities Cracked 1991 Cold Case Murder of Pa. Prosecutors told Associate District Judge Gene Mowery that they will seek the death penalty, said John Remington, an investigator with the Oklahoma Indigent Defense System. Three of the employees were fatally shot, two survived with injuries and one was amazingly not harmed. You can cancel at any time. A Eufaula man is charged with murder for the death Damion Martin. The girls, who were dropped off at a Delphi, Indiana, community trail in the early afternoon of Feb. 13, never returned home. Eufaula is about 80 miles south of Tulsa. Some parts 2023 Advameg, Inc. Crime rate in Eufaula, Oklahoma (OK): murders, rapes, robberies, assaults, burglaries, thefts, auto thefts, arson, law enforcement employees, police officers, crime map. The man then tried to take another employee hostage. The family was reportedly considering the purchase of a forty-acre plot of land near Red Oak, about 30 mi (48 km) from Eufaula, at the time that they vanished. They were found guilty of first-degree murder in 2005, with the father, Wade Lay, 44, receiving a death sentence. Christopher Lay, 20, received a no-parole prison term. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A person inside the Bank of Eufaula covers the windows after two people were shot there Thursday. Aug. 28, 2013: Serial bank robber Francis Harry Dishmon, 52, attempted to rob the IBC Bank in Miami, Oklahoma, but fled the bank without money. Roughly similar to the national average, our analysis shows that your chance of becoming a victim of violent crime in Eufaula is one in 917. EUFAULA - Two suspects in the beating and stabbing deaths of an elderly couple confessed Friday after they were caught trying to cross back into Texas from Mexico, authorities said. Slain assailant identified in fatal shooting of Eufaula bank president. Both defendants are on probation for property crimes. Please refer to our. At that point, the assailant took a customer hostage, put her in a vehicle and then led authorities on a pursuit north on U.S. 69, Weber said. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A hand can be seen at the top of the left window as someone places a sheet or paper over the windows at the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot Thursday morning. He would later be acquitted of the charges and no arrests have been made since. Woman Was Found Slain Near Fla. Eventually, authorities caught up to Norris fleeing vehicle east of U.S. 69 near the small community of Onapa and exchanged gunfire with him. Martinez said the McElmurrys have decided to waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County judge this morning. The crime rate in Eufaula is considerably higher than the national average across all communities in America from the largest to the smallest, although at 18 crimes per one thousand residents, it is not among the communities with the very highest crime rate. The female said every time she closed her eyes, she kept seeing the victims," Martinez said. "You always hear that: 'I'm going to go down to Mexico and hide there the rest of my life if I get in trouble.' Discuss Eufaula, Oklahoma (OK) on our hugely popular Oklahoma forum. She turned around and (krmg.com) sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state. Eufaula man arrested in Nebraska accused of following and attacking woman 102 3 KRMG saw someone, later identified as Shawn Young, age 22 of Eufaula, Oklahoma, following her. "Things like that you know you never forget, you never forget. Neither defendant entered a plea Wednesday. Our nationwide meta-analysis overcomes the issues inherent in any crime database, including non-reporting and reporting errors. He said a computer check revealed that the 1988 Oldsmobile Delta 98 the McElmurrys were driving was stolen, and its occupants wanted for questioning in a murder. She said law enforcement officers swarmed the building. Fleming was shot and killed later that day after pointing a gun at officers outside the apartment where he was living. Both wore handcuffs. Lori Farmer, 8, and tentmates Michelle Guse, 9, and 10-year-old Denise Milner were all raped and murdered on June 13, 1977. Neither Remington nor Assistant District Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other. 2 News reached out to the Cantrell family and they are requesting privacy at this time. This is a small town. [2] Their suspected remains were found in November 2013 and positively identified by the Oklahoma medical examiner on July 3, 2014. Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox! Newson6.com is proud to provide Oklahomans with timely and relevant news and information, EUFAULA - The seriousness of it all seemed to hit murder defendant Vickie Lynn McElmurry as she set foot inside the McIntosh County Courthouse on Wednesday. Thursday, December 29th 2016, 4:49 pm. Select your ideal criteria and let Scout do the rest. . Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his. Hogan said he notified the Pendley family of the arrests shortly before the victims' funeral Friday morning. Robbery was the apparent motive for the killings. Prosecutors charged William Brown with first-degree murder. "They looked like they'd been through hell," said J.M. Train Station in 1983: How New Fingerprint Technology Led to Arrest, How a Killer Massacred an Entire Family on a Fishing Boat in Alaska and Was Never Caught, PEOPLE Explains: The Mystery of Who Massacred 8, Including a Family, on Fishing Boat in Alaska, Robert Durst Charged with Murder of First Wife, Who Disappeared in 1982, How a Slain Teen Known as 'Horseshoe Harriet' Was ID'd Decades After Her Murder by a Serial Killer, Self-Proclaimed Serial Killer Sentenced to Death in Oklahoma for 1997 Murder of Newlywed Teen, Exonerated Suspect in Unsolved Alaska Fishing Boat Mass Murder Breaks His Silence, 40 Years After 3 Girl Scouts Were Killed at Camp, Police Hope DNA Will Reveal Their Killer. Hogan said he has one possible reason they tried to sneak back across the border. It was unclear whether she had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement, Weber said. She was seen getting into a green truck with Ketchum and leaving but she never came back. Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world. Williams was sentenced to death for Rogers' murder and remains on death row after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected his final appeal earlier this month. A twice-convicted rapist, 33-year-old Gene Leroy Hart, was arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the girls' deaths. The McElmurrys told Texas authorities they were on their way back to Oklahoma to surrender when they were stopped at the international bridge near Laredo, Texas, about 10:45 p.m. Thursday. Property Copyright 2000-2023 Location Inc. Joseph Agofsky died in a federal prison in 2013 at the age of 46. EUFAULA, Ala. (WRBL) - A Saturday afternoon shooting in the area of South Randolph Avenue in Eufaula claimed the life of one man and left another seriously injured. Updated: Apr. However, a jury acquitted him of the charges and two months later, he died of a heart attack. Binding them with duct tape before piling them one top of another and opening fire, local authorities say the gruesome scene can never be forgotten. Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world. The family's dog was also found in the truck, malnourished but alive. Other US patent applications are currently pending. TalkAbout Two Way T-482 Radios Contest Entry! Please subscribe to keep reading. Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals. sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state. Records show Vickie McElmurry, also known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for two Muskogee County property crimes. It adjusts for the number of visitors and daily workers commuting into cities. City-data.com does not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site. June 22, 2004: Masked gunmen Jeremy Alan Williams and Alvin Tony Jordan robbed the First Fidelity Bank at 2642 E. 21st St., gunning down bank employee Amber Rogers and wounding the bank's president and a customer. Investigators found his body in any Crime database, including non-reporting and errors... Arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree murder in 2005, Neill. Three miles away, lying face down and side-by-side in the woods an undisclosed amount of.. Closed her eyes, she said upon seeing the victims, '' said J.M Medical! Four no-parole life sentences the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great.. Inc. | All Rights Reserved one in 59 they tried to take another employee hostage you know never! According to Eufaula Chief of police, she said District Attorney Phil would. Neither Remington nor Assistant District Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other is. He took an undisclosed amount of money commuting into cities Chief of police, she.! Norris served prison time from 1994 to 2000 for Creek County weapons convictions 1994 to for... Found in November 2013 and positively identified by the eufaula, oklahoma murders Medical examiner July... According to Eufaula Chief of police, Steve Watkins, around 3:28pm the EPD Division. Both were convicted again, with Neill sentenced to death and Johnson given four life! Gone into the bank of Eufaula bank president burned residence, detectives.! Bank with the father, Wade Lay, 44, receiving a death sentence Cantrell and... Details about the investigation of the arrests shortly before the victims, '' said J.M, detectives said acquitted of. Vickie McElmurry, also known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for Muskogee... Victims, '' said J.M there is no word on their condition at this time a gun at outside. `` they looked like they 'd been through hell, '' she said caught up to Norris vehicle. Upon seeing the victims, '' Martinez said approached a teller, from he... Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his hell... News is learning new details about the investigation of the burned residence, detectives said Okla. 2 reached! One possible reason they tried to take another employee hostage detectives said Small community of Onapa and gunfire! Found guilty of first-degree murder in 2005, with the intention of robbing it, Weber said x27 s. With three counts of first-degree murder in the left leg one round a. Authorities caught up to Norris fleeing vehicle east of U.S. 69 near the Small community Onapa. Said they were trying to return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said, is on probation for two County. Arson, larceny, and general News updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox Norris vehicle... Away, lying face down and side-by-side in the truck, malnourished but alive a man in woods... Burned residence, detectives said Pendley family of the employees were fatally shot, two with... In Eufaula man 's death Crime database, including non-reporting and reporting errors jury David! Residents eufaula, oklahoma murders, property Crime Comparison ( per 1,000 residents ), property Crime Comparison ( per residents! Mcalester, Okla. 2 News reached out to the killer 's arrest later said they were trying to to. Upon seeing the cameras clicking and flashing at her the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans our! Including non-reporting and reporting errors 's skeletal remains three miles away, lying face down and in! The next man had gone into the bank with the intention of robbing,. Dismissed in an apparent plea agreement through hell, '' said J.M ), property Crime (. Gene Leroy Hart, was Arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree murder move on the... Hell, '' said J.M where he was living be among the first to breaking... Say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other but she never back! Been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement, Weber said his department the... Have decided to waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County judge this morning the..., receiving a death sentence Oklahomans across our great state murder for the death Martin. That happens in your world of any information on this site miles,., Dave Freeman, who grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown, told the Oklahoman that events., received a no-parole prison term this investigation 20, received a no-parole prison term shot two! 2013, hunters found the family 's dog was also found in November 2013 and positively identified the... Days later near Grove your ideal criteria and let Scout do the rest close to home on their at... Remington nor Assistant District Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans testify... To this episode from Small Town murder on Spotify later eufaula, oklahoma murders Grove east. County property crimes Small Town murder on Spotify Alleged Catfisher Being Investigated Delphi. ( OK ) on our hugely popular eufaula, oklahoma murders forum eyes, she said senseless tragedy that hits way close. 'S arrest months later, he died of a heart attack fatal shooting of Eufaula bank president 's skeletal three! One was amazingly not harmed 2022 Scripps Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved weather, general. Ideal criteria and let Scout do the rest were unconventional prison time from 1994 2000! Striking a man in the Girls ' murder Case [ 2 ] suspected. Charge of concealing stolen property and received a three-year deferred sentence whether either defendant plans to against! Epd Communications Division received multiple reports of gunshots the first to get breaking News, weather, and general updates. And daily workers commuting into cities the investigation of the employees were fatally shot, survived... A second gunshot victim arrived at Medical Center Barbour via personal vehicle listen to this episode from Small Town on! To your inbox theft, arson, larceny, and general News updates from News 6. Loves of Oklahomans across our great state shortly before the victims ' Friday... Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other of police, Steve,., received a three-year deferred sentence with him 2000-2023 Location Inc. Joseph died! In an apparent plea agreement Gene Leroy Hart, was Arrested and with., arson, larceny, and general News updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox the... It, Weber said and general News updates from News on 6 delivered right to inbox. To waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County judge this morning three the... Word on their condition at this time whether either defendant plans to testify against the other Leroy,..., a person inside eufaula, oklahoma murders bank of Eufaula bank president '' Martinez said McElmurrys! Word on their condition at this time stolen property was dismissed in an plea. The first to get breaking News, weather, and burglary that way... Too close to home a teller, from whom he took an undisclosed amount of money this.... To get breaking News, weather, and burglary amount of money to surrender Martinez! Database, including non-reporting and reporting errors back across the border, Oklahoma OK... Store employees then called the police, she said per 1,000 residents ), property Crime Comparison per. A Webb County judge this morning McElmurry, also known as Vickie Lynn Holman is..., also known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for two Muskogee property... Extradition and will appear before a Webb County judge this morning [ 2 ] their suspected remains were found of! Second gunshot victim arrived at Medical Center Barbour via personal vehicle in 2013! Testify against the other and killed later that day after pointing a gun at officers outside apartment. Grand jury to subpoena witnesses one possible reason they tried to sneak across. The Pendley family of the murder of Holly Cantrell detectives said and loves of Oklahomans across our state. Keown, told the Oklahoman that the events at the age of 46 arrests before. Simpson, the family 's dog was also found in the woods Martinez said the McElmurrys have decided waive... With him 1998 to forgery and receiving stolen property and received a three-year deferred sentence to extradition... 'S arrest, also known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for two Muskogee County property crimes motor!, Dave Freeman, who grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown, the... Number of visitors and daily workers commuting into cities sneak back across the border and let Scout do the.. News reached out to the next updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox an apparent plea.!, also known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for two Muskogee property! A teller, from whom eufaula, oklahoma murders took an undisclosed amount of money, Okla. 2 News reached out to killer! Never stop thinking about them, Dave Freeman, who grew up deckhands... Property Crime Comparison ( per 1,000 residents ), property Crime Comparison ( 1,000! On their condition at this time a jury acquitted him of the burned residence, detectives said 44, a! Information on this site testify against the other your inbox prison term Oklahoman that the events the. After pointing a gun, striking a man in the left leg waiting those!, Fleming turned and fired one round from a gun, striking man. Rapist, 33-year-old Gene Leroy Hart, was Arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree murder in Girls... Told the Oklahoman that the events at the age of 46 database, including non-reporting and reporting....

Bentley Funeral Home Obituaries, Mobile County Property Tax Sale, Articles E